Idea

The way you envision it, yes…definitely.

Someone is going to have to do the work to keep you satisfied. Meet your needs, house feed and cloth you. In private business you are paid to preform these tasks. The buyer buys these goods so they don’t have to make them.

Again, who pays for it?

How?

Okay let’s hear your plan for transitioning to this co-op system of no payment for services render.

I ask her this every time and never a response

No you don’t

It can’t be done without establishing an absolute dictatorship to make people surrender what they own privately.

I don't have any private property

That’s irrelevant. Other people do. Now how do you plan to get them to give it up?

Your body! If the people supplying the power want it, they get it! Or into the mass grave you go!

I can use force. I don't really care about the lives of private property owners anyway

Ah, there it is: the requirement to form an absolute dictatorship in order to make everyone do what you want. Well, little communist, Molon labe

Would you force someone to stop killing people if you could

We have laws that stop them! You can call the cops and wait or defend yourself! Unless you are in a blue state then you go to prison for defending yourself! There is no right to safety in this country! That is the individual's responsibility!

Apples and oranges

Well here is your chance again.. Explain in detail how your plan will work, Logistics, Laws and all. Assuming everyone agrees to your plan, how does it work? who is in charge? who does what job? what if people do not want that Job etc etc etc

We??
You mean “you”.

Like Hiroshima got it

Do i get to choose what you pay for my "work?"

Again, who pays for it????!!

We all do

Not you.

No, just a troll

so you took your mothers maiden name?? lol aka her dads name
so everyone is supposed to give up their stuff? again you first..

No, YOU don’t get it.

I think I'm starting to get it. But still our government is to corrupted to get rid of capitalism. Even non profits have become a loophole for government money. It boils down to the haves and have not with a dash of greed.

Yass 😍😍😍

The part your not getting is that this already exists, social security is a public service, anyone working for dhhs is a public service, yet you have companies scamming Medicaid and Medicare with fake or fraudulent claims. Look at all the businesses that took millions of dollars in forgivable loans during COVID fraudulently. Public servants such as police and a public librarian, still can cripple the budget. I guess they have more rules and over site than private business, and that is where our government has failed. After Enron nothing has been the same. If the government had the power to set standards, a tax on profits that exceed a threshold, that would make businesses more likely to lower prices. If the government audits business practices, and would take the human rights away from corporations, people wouldn't become their personal piggy bank, and human shield. But corporations have the same if not more rights than the governments citizens. They are the first to get bailed out always.

“ But corporations have the same if not more rights than the governments citizens.”
We are NOT citizens of the government. We are citizens of this country. The government is supposed to work for us, be under the control of us.
That is exactly what the MAGA movement is all about…returning control of our government and our very lives back to US, the American Citizens.

Without the government to issue me a social security number I would not be considered a citizen. Even if the government worked for its citizens, it still would protect the corporations who injure it's citizens. Even if the people had the power to control the government, it still might go against personal beliefs.