I'm not part of the "Christian Right", but as mostly Libertarian I would say it's fine with me, and I would speculate most Conservatives wouldn't care, since they believe in freedom, unlike lefties.
In your hypothetical scenario, this guy is the coach of a team that just finished a game, right carjaker?
I mean, you are making an apples to apples comparison here, right? Otherwise he'd just be some nutjob troublemaker trying to make an inane point, which is what this meme is actually doing.