I’ve never said it was the officers fault. I’ve simply said the following.
1. People are innocent until proven guilty.
2. Law enforcement are not infallible.
3. Not every person a cop stops is a criminal.
4. Obeying the law and police compliance are not the same thing.
The problem with your example is you assume I would break the law. It completely supports my theory that you believe everyone is guilty until proven innocent.
Let's walk YOU through anther example here. Let’s say you’re driving around and to the best of your knowledge you are not speeding because you’re a law abiding citizen like you like to think you are. Yet, you see police lights because you have, perhaps unknowingly, broken a traffic law.
Now, both me and you would likely pull over. I’d likely comply to a point until the officer asks me to step out of my vehicle. If the officer has failed to inform me of what I’ve done and his insistence of my compliance escalates, I’m pulling out my keys and locking the car until I’ve been informed if I’m being detained or free to go.
Now you, on the other hand would likely do anything the cop tells you. You’d give him your name, number, address, tell him what you’re doing, where you’re headed, your wife or mother’s maiden name, your social security, your first born child, your wallet, your money, hop on one leg, dance like a monkey, or suck his dick.
Personally, I just don’t think I have to comply to every command. Yes, one should exercise common sense but that doesn’t mean every officer you’re going to run into will be reasonable or have your well-being as a top priority.