Lie.

No, personal property is a subset of private property. You're trying a distinction without a difference. And a thing to can to make a thing of value falls under your private property as well.

False. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_property
Atrempting to change the devotion doesn't make you right, it shows you're afraid you're wrong.

I'm not trying to take away your right to have your own house or car. I'm not after your phone. I'm after the people who enclose and make money off commons such as water, beaches, forests, healthcare, public goods, shelter, music, and even knowledge itself.

I need your phone or the devise you are using to access this site. It is a good sacrifice of your private property. Let me know when you are ready for me to give you an address to send it to.

No, you are. I've rented and now own a home.

Private property is anything that is privately owned, however it may be used.

You just admitted to doing exactly what you said you're not in the same sentence.

There’s nothing wrong with owning a tenement house. In fact it is actually preferable for many because they don’t have to pay for repairs and upkeep like a home owner does. This means a landlord is doing a major service for lower income people.

Saying landlords provide a service is like saying if I held a knife to your throat and told you to do something for me to keep me from cutting your head of, I'm providing you with a head. Landlords don't provide, they take.

Real-estate/property tax pays for a lot, where is the gov going to get the revenue if that is gone?

Your way millions would be homeless

What about free housing for all

What do you call the device that you post to imagflip from? Technically, it’s private property. And under what you propose, the state can take it from you anytime the state wants, because the state considers it property of the state. And you get no compensation.

It's not. I don't make money off it

That is irrelevant.

how are you communicating here then? cell, laptop, Pc?

Personal property

tamato/tamato

"What about free housing for all" you asked at the end of thread
Nothing is free, who pays for the bricks and morter and labor of the housing?
Just seize someone's investment? Like Hitler?

People can use converters, smart phones, laptops etc to sell items they make, like what I do on eBay. That makes it capital to me as it’s a tool to my business. Just because you use yours to play video games and and post fantasy about how much better you think you can make the world by communism instead is on you. It’s still possible to make money, therefore you need to surrender it.

Well I don't make money off of it. I don't use my phone to extract money from the public, and I don't have more than I need.

But yet you could if you wanted to. That’s still an asset.