"Ah yes, this SCOTUS opinion that copiously cited 18th-century mens’ journals, while throwing modern feminist writings in the trash heap not to mention 50 years of its own precedent."
I gotta admit, after reading that first sentence, I'm not particularly motivated to read any further. We went from me claiming you have been duped by a lying media, and you seeking "honest, thoughtful conservatives who can provide a balanced and unbiased introduction into contemporary pro-life thought?", to straight up SCOTUS bashing. (with some opinion about the current and future happenings re; abortion in general)
Okay, so you pretty much don't believe in the legitimacy of the SCOTUS when it hands down a ruling with which you disagree... am I right? OR, perhaps you were more inclined to find them legitimate when they ruled against the Trump era 'stay in Mexico' policy that Biden wanted tossed out? (just asking, since I don't pretend to know your position on the latter topic)
"This opinion argues only that states *can* ban abortion. What it doesn’t say: *should* states ban abortion? And under what circumstances? What other laws should be passed to complement a “pro-life” agenda, if any?"
Why would they weigh in on any of those subjects, when the ruling clearly says this is a states' rights issue? You seem pretty sharp, so I'm surprised you didn't pick up on that, or perhaps just chose to ignore it.
You make many strong points in the rest of your post. I'm not saying I agree or disagree with them, just that they're good points. Maybe the real discussion should be whether the concept of states' rights should be applied as consistently and broadly as a court that swings as far to the right as this one does, seems to want? That's a pretty broad subject, but if there were some way to legitimately address that, then it might be easier to set up the framework for a federal level law on abortion rights. Problem being the Constitution itself, which clearly states that any powers not specifically defined within it, are for the states. Obviously that's gone out the window as far as being strictly followed, so perhaps there are ways for abortion rights to find their way back to a federal level.