Perhaps I'm being unfair, as I've not caught much of him on Fox (CNN was on occasion when I was visiting and my mother was watching it. He seemed cool enough then).
I tried watching The Five, I did, on account of Gutfeld, Red Eye being muh fave tv show 'n all. Then also later on account of Juan Williams after NPR dicked him for being honest. But the rest of the panel was like watching mannequins with shrill voices piped into your ear at full blast, and Guthead went all post-Dean Martin Jerry Lewis sour dour.
Even worse is he brought that persona onto Red Eye. Ugh.
He finally got the hint and tried becoming our fave clown again, but it was too late and seemed forced, much as his Saturday nite Red Eye imitation show does. Frig, the guy even pauses for the audience to laugh on his cue now. So lame. It's like Glen Danzig, bought into his own mythology.