I viewed this episode. Got a great laugh out of the whole multiple recycling bins gag. I'd like to think I would have told them to go take a hike. I would do no more than 3.
One of their arguments is that it take you a lot of work to do all this recycling. Currently in my municipality we have a single stream system so gosh only 1 bin to worry about. So when I say 3 I mean trash, recycling, and composting, which I do so I wouldn't even do 3 unless I lived in an apartment.
As for recycling taking more trees that is a insidious argument. If there are more trees today they certainly aren't bigger and more diverse. We need more land trusts not more land fills, albeit you could and should plant trees there.
Really what we need to be doing is growing things like hemp which is vastly more efficient that trees at making paper. Too bad it took forever for government to re-legalize the growing of it. Wonder what Penn and Teller would say about that???
As far as landfills are just fine no that's not the case as no one wants one anywhere close to them. In fact no one wants even a processing facility anywhere close to them where the trash isn't even stored there. Our trash just keeps getting shipped further and further away... How environmental is that? I know this because of what's going on in my own community concerning this issue. So yes, landfill space is an issue.
I think the best argument they may have is that it costs more energy to transport, process, and re-transport to wherever than it may cost from scratch, but I didn't see any solid numbers on that.
Regardless on an environmental level the best thing we could do is to have very little trash and or recycling. The less items to ship to wherever the better. This means if we grew our own food and or shopped in bulk without all the wrappings, and had very little leftovers, etc we wouldn't have very much trash or recycling. However in this society it's really hard not to shop, and there is plenty of needless packaging so it's kind of hard to avoid it all together without so super serious effort that I'm even not willing to do. So what's the solution?
Ideally everything would be made high quality and last a really long time.... or any temporary items would easily decompose and would be composted and truly recycled. Even better if the composting could be done right at home which I do. And no it's not nasty because you don't use meats & oils etc & you cover with leaves etc, leaving you with dark rich soil