Your argument is a masterclass in historical revisionism and moral bankruptcy, so let’s dismantle it with the contempt it deserves. The claim that “Palestine” doesn’t exist is not just ignorant—it’s a deliberate erasure of a people, their history, and their identity. Palestine, as a geographic and cultural entity, has existed for centuries, long before the modern state of Israel was established in 1948. It’s documented in ancient texts, Ottoman records, and British Mandate maps. To deny its existence is to spit in the face of historical fact and the lived reality of millions.Your assertion that “most real Palestinians” are dead—whether by IDF actions, suicide attacks, or old age—is a grotesque caricature, dripping with dehumanizing cynicism. Palestinians, like any people, are not a monolith defined by violence or extinction. Over 5 million Palestinians live today in the occupied territories and diaspora, their identity forged through shared history, culture, and resilience despite decades of displacement and oppression. To reduce them to “Israelis of Palestinian extraction” is a semantic sleight-of-hand, stripping them of agency and nationhood while ignoring the systemic denial of their rights under Israeli law. Citizenship doesn’t erase identity—especially when that citizenship often comes with second-class status.And then there’s your crowning gem: labeling Palestinians who resist—whether with a rock or a gun—as “traitors” to Israel, deserving of punishment. This is the logic of a bully who punches someone in the face and then calls them a criminal for daring to push back. Resistance doesn’t make someone a traitor to a state that occupies their land, demolishes their homes, and restricts their basic freedoms. It’s a response to injustice, not a betrayal of some fabricated loyalty. Your argument reeks of colonial arrogance, demanding submission from a people you’ve already written off as extinct.In short, your claims aren’t just wrong—they’re a venomous attempt to whitewash history and justify oppression. Palestine exists, Palestinians endure, and your rhetoric only exposes the fragility of a worldview that relies on erasure to function. Try harder, Trumper.
