Mumbo literally made an item sorter for
non-stackable items
There is no reason for this to be hated
if we didn't get the phantom we wouldn't have slow falling potions
If we didn't get the glow squid we wouldn't be able to see signs as easily as we can now, but some type of glowing potion using the glow ink sacs would've been good. You'd be able to glow in the dark and not have to place torches constantly.
And if we didn't get the allay we could've gotten the glare, it just tells you when it's dark, Why would anyone need that. Or we would've gotten the copper golem which just presses buttons. We can do that, and we can do it at long range with a bow or we can use a dispenser and a target block or another button, heck even tripwire
The allay is the best thing we could've gotten out of that vote