Hmmm

This contains a paradox, in that if the murderer did not kill anyone they would not be a murderer...can you clarify?

That is what I was going to say

ah because this was in a video game called murder mystery and one of the roles is murderer

Ohh I figured the reason everyone was looking for him was because he killed someone before, thus earning him the murderer title.

Okay, so I'm assuming that the 'murderer' is convicted but has not actually committed murder, which would make the sheriff the murderer.

yup

Wait... I think that the sheriff killed himself.

*X files theme plays*

its red, i saw him vent

It's a video game. fun one at that.
so I have to say that The murderer is well the Murderer. and Only cause he was given that role. and he didn't play it correctly

AHA. Super smart, but technically they are both murderers

not if it was self defence

*defense

The murderer killed many of people hence the name murderer so he has to be a murderer therefore he killed someone

sherrif, a murderer can't be a murderer if they never murdered anyone from the beginning

The sheriff is not a murderer is the accused is guilty, but it is not first degree murder if the sheriff thinks that the accused is guilty though they are innocent

Its not murder its suicide

Technically the murderer is the sheriff so its suicide

Depends on what the "murder" was doing.

Well the way this would go is technically he is the murderer so he would of killed someone so he is still the murderer and no matter what the sheriff is also the murder so yeah suicide

You forgot the third option self-defense.

BuT He KiLlEd No OnE

The sheriff is the murder duh what a lame meme and this person hated on my meme first

first I never hated on your meme, I was just pointing out something

Excuse me sir. I would like to tell you that this is not a meme, it's a question. and tht on the think tank do do not support negitivity.

Pretty sure if it's a murderer, they're the real murderer. Otherwise, they wouldn't be called a murderer.

There is no real murderer. It's a paradox.

"If There" is the sheriff, and also the murderer.