"So if your not an athiest, we will kill you."
I don't see how that's any different than "if you're not a Christian, I'll kill you" or "if you're not a Muslim I'll kill you."
The point of this meme is not that athiesm is bad, it is that the claim that athiesm is better than religion because no one has ever killed in the name of athiesm, is bull shit.
There are good Christians and bad Christians. There are good Muslims and bad Muslims. There are good athiests and bad athiests.
But no bad Wiccans, Wiccans rock.