Imgflip Logo Icon
WHICH ONE IS TRUE? | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
44 views 1 upvote Made by Spaceguru 1 week ago in The_Think_Tank
11 Comments
4 ups, 1w
It's true that they both exist. Only one of them covers a subject I can really get into.
0 ups, 5d,
2 replies
Neither is absolute truth. The one on the left is a pretty good read, but it's legend; the one on the right is written by a doctor, but I'd want to know more about it before I declared it "true".
1 up, 5d
Fair point, though in the case of The Va**na Bible, there are parts where Dr. Gunter admits she doesn't have all the answers and that further studies need to be done.
[deleted]
0 ups, 4d,
2 replies
2 ups, 3d
Prove that it's historical.
2 ups, 4d,
1 reply
Lol, prove that it's not. Oh wait, the whole point of faith is that it has no proof. So you can either concede that proof is beside the point, or undermine the position that religion requires faith. Your move. I want to see what makes people like you tick.
[deleted]
0 ups, 4d,
1 reply
2 ups, 4d,
1 reply
I held up a mirror. What you interpreted in the reflection is on you.
[deleted]
0 ups, 4d,
2 replies
2 ups, 4d
I don't like closed-mindedness, trolls, logical fallacies, and people who refuse to cop to their own bullshit. So, it's less wrong to say that I really don't like people who act like you.
1 up, 3d
It's great to be curious. Now, be curious about the text.

The books of the Torah took their current form in the Persian period (The 6th to 4th century BCE), yet much of the legendary history they recount happened at least 500 years earlier. That means that the stories were passed down orally, like the legends in Homer, for centuries before being written down. There may well be some historical truth there (there WAS a first temple, as there WAS a city in the spot where the legendary Troy was supposed to be), but the text is not history.

Similarly, the Gospels were written some 40 - 80 years after the death of Jesus, when it's unlikely that anyone who'd met him when they were an adult would still be alive. Stories were handed down orally until then, and the inclusion of new material in the later Gospels (hello, adorable story about shepherds in the Book of Luke!) is probably a literary fabrication.

If reading the books gives you comfort and spiritual enlightenment, that's fine. But they meet the criteria for legends. (Here's one take on that: https://bookriot.com/the-difference-between-myth-fairy-tale-and-legend/ ).
Created with the Imgflip Meme Generator
IMAGE DESCRIPTION:
WHICH ONE IS TRUE?