A Kafka Trap is a type of logical fallacy where an accusation is made, and any attempt to deny or argue against it is taken as evidence of guilt. This fallacy is named after Franz Kafka’s novel “The Trial,” where the protagonist Josef K. is accused of crimes without knowing what they are or being able to defend himself.
Key Characteristics:
Accusation without specifics: The accusation lacks clear details or evidence, making it impossible to refute or defend against.
Denial as evidence: Any attempt to deny or argue against the accusation is seen as proof of guilt, rather than a legitimate response.
Circular and unfalsifiable: The argument is self-referential and cannot be disproven, as the accuser’s goal is to trap the accused in a web of guilt, regardless of the truth.