It doesn't keep the sheep asleep because they can be unplugged from the Matrix in the "real world" and Morpheus only seemed interested in Neo (aka "The Anomaly.") No red pill-blue pill thing is needed to do that. "To have a movie" is the out-of-universe perspective. So from an in-universe perspective, why bother?
The machines knew about "The Anomaly" (Neo) and recognized a pattern was repeating. Humans playing around inside the Matrix wasn't going to break that pattern or machine control.