Imgflip Logo Icon

From what I've read, this girl is still alive. Tl;dr - these parents should be referred to child protective services.

From what I've read, this girl is still alive. Tl;dr - these parents should be referred to child protective services. | Any child who is under 18 years of age lacks the mental capacity to make life-and-death decisions. That's the same argument conservatives love to deploy about transgender care, after all, and that issue doesn't even involve the weightiness of life-and-death. File that away as you read the rest of this. For their latest trick, anti-vaxxers are pushing the story of Yulia Hicks, a 14-year-old with a terminal illness, claiming she's on her way to becoming a martyr for allegedly being denied a transplant after refusing the COVID vaccine. *Another reminder: Medical decision-making is extremely complex. Given the unreliability and anti-vaxx skew of the only sources who are sharing this story, I doubt all the relevant context about the medical details of her case have been included. Namely, she may have been denied a transplant for a combination of non-politically charged reasons, like incompatibility, in which case this story is being virally shared by anti-vaxxers for no reason at all. Anyway. Assuming the refusal of a COVID vaccine actually did factor into treatment decisions here, remember: *she* doesn't have the capacity to make such a choice, independent of undue parental influence. She's simply not old enough. THIS ORPHAN WAS RESCUED FROM UKRAINE, BUT SADLY, SHE MAY BE THE NEXT CASUALTY OF A VERY AMERICAN PROBLEM: COVID DISINFORMATION. | image tagged in talking to putin trolls,yulia hicks,covid,covid-19,coronavirus,anti-vaxx | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
294 views 13 upvotes Made by Slobama 2 years ago in politicsTOO
4 Comments
2 ups, 2y,
1 reply
That was a lot of words, but there's simply no way to debunk propaganda this manipulative without providing the detail.

More on how this story came to my attention: imgflip.com/i/73m0zq?nerp=1670618401#com22647665

Reminder that while COVID has waned in death rates and has mostly dropped out of the headlines, anti-vaxxers haven't gone away. Disgusting to see how they are now using cases like this 14-year-old girl's as a prop to further undermine trust in modern medicine and propagate COVID disinformation designed to kill yet more people.

If this girl is still alive, I hope someone in a position of authority can intervene to save her.
1 up, 2y
vladimir putin smiling | COVID DISINFO KILLS A UKRAINIAN CHILD? I'M TRYING AS HARD AS I CAN
TO FINISH THE HOLODOMOR | image tagged in vladimir putin smiling | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
[deleted]
2 ups, 2y
I mean, tough call for sure. I know nada about the situation. Personally I always try to give parents more leeway than not. If she/they don't want a shot and are denied a transplant, that's pretty lousy on the part of the hospital IMO.

But for sure they shouldn't be fed misinfo either. Especially with that Novavax shot out. That one is about as inarguably harmless as a shot will ever get, haha.
[deleted]
0 ups, 2y
I’m not anti vaxx I’m trying to learn more and I’m sorry for starting this whole thing
I didn’t even realize I was knee deep into this until I read all of the comments because I have a social disorder and I don’t pick up on social cues
Created with the Imgflip Meme Generator
EXTRA IMAGES ADDED: 1
  • Talking to Putin trolls
  • Yulia Hicks
  • IMAGE DESCRIPTION:
    Any child who is under 18 years of age lacks the mental capacity to make life-and-death decisions. That's the same argument conservatives love to deploy about transgender care, after all, and that issue doesn't even involve the weightiness of life-and-death. File that away as you read the rest of this. For their latest trick, anti-vaxxers are pushing the story of Yulia Hicks, a 14-year-old with a terminal illness, claiming she's on her way to becoming a martyr for allegedly being denied a transplant after refusing the COVID vaccine. *Another reminder: Medical decision-making is extremely complex. Given the unreliability and anti-vaxx skew of the only sources who are sharing this story, I doubt all the relevant context about the medical details of her case have been included. Namely, she may have been denied a transplant for a combination of non-politically charged reasons, like incompatibility, in which case this story is being virally shared by anti-vaxxers for no reason at all. Anyway. Assuming the refusal of a COVID vaccine actually did factor into treatment decisions here, remember: *she* doesn't have the capacity to make such a choice, independent of undue parental influence. She's simply not old enough. THIS ORPHAN WAS RESCUED FROM UKRAINE, BUT SADLY, SHE MAY BE THE NEXT CASUALTY OF A VERY AMERICAN PROBLEM: COVID DISINFORMATION.