The Constitution also says that the IP stream should be a model democracy. If scar can ban people on a whim, despite a majority vote to undo that by congress, then it is not a democracy, but a totalitarian regime. A Congress that has no power is useless, and an owner that has unlimited power is authoritarian.
In regards to a compromise, I think one can be reached, as well as letting IG back in. But nobody yet has actually asked me for my input, so I've kept quiet.