admit that i'm right about this

A character in the books I write myself always says "An amateur kills people. A pro makes them suffer!"
I didn't want Dolores Umbridge to die... As long as she's alive she can suffer.... All the way into insanity.... That would serve her right!

true

So you're saying you'd want her to suffer the same curse as the Longbottoms? Does anyone really deserve it? Even Umbridge?? Sure she was awful, but no-one deserves an unforgivable curse...

Hehehe... I guess my upbringing caused me to learn to hate people in a really targeted manner. But maybe we don't even need unforgivable curses. Umbridge got a life sentence in Azkaban, and although the dementors were removed by Kingsley Shacklebolt, who became minister for Magic after Voldemort's downfall, I've know that a life long sentence is enough to drive anybody crazy. I know that in the Netherlands, were a life-long sentence means you really are in jail until the day you die (parole is very hard to get and requires a personal pardon from the king himself and is rarely given), I did hear some inmates serving a life-long imprisonment that they'd rather have been executed in stead. This means they already suffer.

Death is the easy way out of everything. In Death Umbridge cannot repent for what she had done. Alive facing severe punishment, she can... The world is not just divided in unforgivable curses and going completely off the hook.

So what you're saying is that she suffered just by being alive. Not physically tortured, but emotionally. I get that. It is better to have her pay for her sins in life, as opposed to in death. Though we don't know if she really will be. Did she ever apologize to Harry? Did she admit she was wrong? If she didnt, I dont know if even a lifetime of suffering can save her in death.

It was never noted in detail if she did. I know for one thing that some real-life inmates serving a life-long sentence don't regret anything at all. Still they are in payment for what they did. Death wouldn't have changed them either. In Umbridge's case... I just wanted her to pay for what she did, and death would be to cheap for the likes of her. Life long in prison or being tortured physically were not the thing that mattered to me, as long as she pays for what she's done. Umbridge was a rather weak and pathetic woman constantly allying her self with those who gave her power, and that ultimately backfired on her. And seeing how she did things when she did not get things done the way she intended, shows she won't like her time in Azkaban and that it will likely frustrate the hell out of her. Even without the Dementors. And that counts for a lot.

Lol Believe me no ones mind will be changed

Also knew Voldemort would die so no surprise either

I wanted her to die... slowly... painfully...

lol

true.

i gotta give ya that one