New York City election stats:
2012:
Obama: 1,995,241 (81.2%)
Romney: 436,889 (17.8%)
2008:
Obama: 2,074,159 (79.3%)
McCain: 524,787 (20.1%)
2004:
Kerry: 1,828,015 (75.0%)
Bush: 587,534 (24.1%)
2000:
Gore: 1,708,632 (77.9%)
Bush: 400,922 (18.3%)
1996:
Clinton: 1,512,248 (77.1%)
Dole: 339,537 (17.3%)
1992:
Clinton: 1,458,784 (68.7%)
Bush: 509,423 (24.0%)
(Shockingly low Perot numbers)
1998:
Dukakis: 1,340,795 (66.2%)
Bush: 665,407 (32.8%)
1984:
Mondale: 1,343,875 (61.0%)
Reagan: 852,317 (38.7%)
1980:
Carter: 1,052,178 (54.9%)
Reagan: 719,278 (37.5%)
1976:
Carter: 1,423,380 (66.4%)
Ford: 706,663 (32.9%)
1972:
McGovern: 1,342,996 (51.5%)
Nixon: 1,259,873 (48.3%)
(This one was actually close!)
1968:
Humphrey: 1,582,681 (60.1%)
Nixon: 886,959 (33.9%)
1964:
Johnson: 2,183,643 (73.0%)
Goldwater: 801,877 (26.8%)
1960:
Kennedy: 1,936,323 (62.6%)
Nixon: 1,145,205 (37.0%)
Something from a forum