Inception

Not really I am not sure if they even have the concept of boarders no one is because we can't communicate with them. What we do know is that in every instance of contact except 1 violence has come about

I'm Christian and believe we, as Christians, need to spread the gospel to all the world, but even I don't think he should have entered.

So we are justified in killing people who come across our border without permission then, right?

So they are justified in killing to defend their land, but not us.. what is so special about them that they are justified to murder?

So you're saying that people coming here should be killed by arrows?

No I'm trying to point out how absurd it is that he says they were completely justified in killing him.

My bad, I just followed one of OM's comments here and didn't read the whole thread because I'm watching TWD for the nth time and it was a commercial and I was rushing...

I understand they were known for doing this and the island was off limits to all outsiders. And while he knew better and thus risked bringing this upon himself, I personally can't justify what they did. But from their pov, they were.

It is against the law to go to their island. It is against the law to come here without coming through a port of entry. Both are breaking the law and trespassing. Yet you give them free reign to kill because "they're scared". It's also against the law in India to murder, last I checked.

And that guy posed no threat to their community. Other than disease, and tying up his body and dragging him around exposed them to that anyway so they didn't defend themselves from it at all.

From their perspective they were, but to say they were justified, sounds like you're justifying it as well. Given the particulars, I can see where you're coming from, it's just that it sounds...

Hmmm, as we've seen many a time justified by our resident NRA members.

But in that case it was some stupid kid on what he considered to be a good mission.
While ingnorant, naive, arrogant, and insulting, his intent was not malicious.

He must have been mentally ill, and not exceptionally bright. Plus wonder how he got the money, his parents sure did him right.

I disagree, just because the plethora of prophets and the multiple Second Comings of Jesus I've witnessed may seem nothing more than ranting schizophrenic homeless in the Subway, doesn't mean they were.

I wish someone would have killed him before he made it to the island and risked all their lives with disease, also scaring the shit out of them by screeching at them in another language about some insane religious bullshit! They probably have their own religion and this dipshit was obviously not there to ask them about THEIR beliefs...

boi thats called enforcing law