Imgflip Logo Icon

"Why No Polygraph For Kavanaugh?"

"Why No Polygraph For Kavanaugh?" | I Plead The Fifth. | image tagged in brett kavanaugh,supreme court,trump's bad judgment,polygraph,lie detector test,i plead the fifth | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
6,722 views 3 upvotes Made by AArchibald 6 years ago in fun
brett kavanaughsupreme court
trump's bad judgment
polygraph
lie detector test
i plead the fifth
10 Comments
2 ups, 6y,
1 reply
Because an accusation isn't proof of wrong doing and he has the presumption of innocence until PROVEN guilty! Basic law there Chuckles!
0 ups, 6y
You and I agree that accusation is not proof.

However, eye witness testimony - now offered by several credible accusers - does carry evidentiary weight in courts of law.

Even more fundamentally, Kavanaugh's senate hearings do not constitute a "Court of Law."

Rather, the purpose of these hearings is to present testimony before The Court of Public Opinion.

In The Court of Public Opinion, people pass judgment apart from "the rules of evidence" and "the presumption of innocence" that apply in Courts of Law.

This is how senate hearings are designed to play out. Fundamentally, Kavanaugh is the subject of a "job interview."

Yesterday, Trump himself admitted he could change his mind on Kavanaugh according to what he "sees" in today's testimony by Dr. Christine Blasey Ford.

This distinction between a "Court of Law" and "The Court of Public Opinion" parallels the divergent outcomes of O.J. Simpson's two trials: O.J. was declared "not guilty" in "criminal court" but was convicted in "civil court."

Similarly, since polygraphs are sometimes unreliable, "lie detection" does not qualify as legal proof.

However, as a general rule, polygraph testing is far more reliable than not.

I have long noted that "conservatives" demand "perfection" whenever "perfection" works to their ideological advantage.

Then these same "conservatives" sign off on "imperfect" monstrosities like Trump without a hint of cognitive dissonance.

"Is Perfectionism A Curse? Paul Ryan Tells The Truth."
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2012/09/is-perfectionism-curse-paul-ryan-tells.html
1 up, 6y,
1 reply
Because polygraphs are unreliable.
0 ups, 6y,
1 reply
Polygraphs are sometimes unreliable.

But as a general rule they are far more reliable than not.

I have long noted that "conservatives" demand perfection whenever "perfection" works to their ideological advantage.

then these same "conservatives" sign off on "imperfect" monstrosities like Trump without a hint of cognitive dissonance.

"Is Perfectionism A Curse? Paul Ryan Tells The Truth."
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2012/09/is-perfectionism-curse-paul-ryan-tells.html
1 up, 6y,
1 reply
Unreliability at any time relegates the test as untenable.
0 ups, 6y,
1 reply
Nothing is perfect. In medical testing, there are - inevitably - false negatives and false negatives. We do not throw out the baby with the bath.
1 up, 6y
We do not accept lie detectors in court which means we shouldn't give them too much credence.
0 ups, 6y,
1 reply
Still no criminal investigation opened by the jurisdiction in which the alleged event occurred.... I wonder why? Could it be there is nothing there?
0 ups, 6y,
1 reply
I wonder why. Could it be there is something there?
0 ups, 6y
No effort on your behalf in that argument. Try harder next time.
Created with the Imgflip Meme Generator
IMAGE DESCRIPTION:
I Plead The Fifth.