Just do a home run Derby to break the tie. Everybody loves the home run Derby! Each team picks three batters that were on the field in the ninth inning, or the 10th if you play one extra training. Put the ball machine out there and crank it 94 miles an hour. Alternate teams .Each batter gets three pitches in a row. A home run counts three points. Any ball that’s fair is two poisnts. Any foul ball is one point. A swing and miss get zero points. Add additional batters if needed.
No change to the final score. Team that wins home run Derby gets the win.