oh Andrew definitely has a good and a bad side tho

well it depends on what you mean by it

like
you can be on his "good side" if he likes you, or his "bad side" if he doesn't like you (in that case idk what the "rule breaker/follower" sides mean)

or if you mean he has the angel and devil on his shoulder telling him to be bad or good

um
no
he has a history of being intentionally inconsistent with rule enforcement and it's usually based on whether he likes someone or not

take silver for example

mc?