another lie cropping up

Appears inevitable

Wow. How privileged of you.

So you think the jobs illegals were doing are shit jobs?

So you think the jobs illegal were doing are desirable jobs?

They are to someone. A paycheck is always desirable.

If that job, desirable or not, was unnecessary, then it wouldn't exist. Nobody would want to pay someone to do it.

So desirable or not, all people have a right to work and earn a living? And that illegals, provide a vital service by doing jobs that benefit our economy? Construction, vegetable harvesting, farming, processing plants, hotel staff, etc. And were shooting ourselves in the foot by removing those people WILLING to do less desirable, low paying jobs, that the majority of Americans refuse to do?

"all people have a right to work and earn a living"

Globally as a human right, sure.

Specifically in America, no. All US citizens have that right. All people who aren't US citizens have the opportunity to apply for citizenship. All people have a responsibility to follow these laws if they want to enjoy the opportunities America provides.

"illegals provide a vital service"

No. Illegals do not provide any service that UA citizens cannot also provide.

"jobs the majority of Americans refuse to do"

Nope. As reality is currently proving, there are Americans willing to get off government support and ddo these jobs. The metric I posted proves it.

Continuing to reduce the government support will encourage those refusing to do those jobs to reconsider. This isn't even an EvIl DrUmPftftf CoNcEpT, it was a Bill Clinton policy.

Your argument is speculative . Assuming removal of the present migrant system, a system that has been in place and supported by American business, for decades, could be easily replaced? Then that system would be in existence today.

Americans willing to get off Government support and do these jobs? Given that thought process, is confusing. Why did they choose to receive Government assistance instead of getting a jobs to begin with?

I'm certain you will ask, what proof do I have?

Best example; Trump has had illegals working at his hotels since the 20th century. If Trump could have replaced them? Don't you believe Trump would have? Cost efficiency is the key. Without it? No cost efficiency? prices rise exponentially

receive Government assistance instead of getting a jobs to begin with?

when illegals fill all the low skill jobs, nothing is left. this isn't difficult.

I don't know where you live. Or, what sort of employment you performed.Or, if you know, or, have even seen, the jobs migrant workers perform?
Trust me, the jobs illegals work? Since after the time of the great depression? Have never been filled by Americans.
That is a fact

I'm not going to bother researching when the shift to migrant labor happened or when illegal immigrants became the predominant group filling those positions. trying to use precedent of recent times is garbage. prior to the Great depression assuming that is correct all of those jobs were filled by Americans typically you learning work ethic. do you want to go down the rabbit hole of deciphering why work ethic is such a premium now and why so few Young Americans seem to have it? I don't think that you do.

I can't help but notice that you have backed off considering these jobs undesirable. that's an improvement.

What metric did you post proves it? There's produce rotting on the ground. Family farmers haven't been able to get their own children to work on their family farm in how many years? That's why when they inherit the family farm, the family farmers' kids sell the family farm.

In fact, there's such a surplus of farms for sale that not only were corporations buying, but increasingly larger number of Saudis and Chinese have been too.

The job numbers are following the same trajectory that they have been since President Barack Hussein Obama, save for the dip during the Covid Lockdown. Nobody's lining up to take jobs milking cows at 2 hours before dawn. They couldn't even if they wanted to, their soft little hands would probably crumble in under 20 minutes.

There have been hundreds of thousands of jobs in manufacturing open since Biden, and no takers. That didn't change overnight then, and it's not going to change overnight now. People like cushy air conditioned cubicle jobs were they get to play on social media all day without their employers noticing. They're not about to do anything that requires anything more strenuous than twirling around in a swivel chair as they reach for a sip of their Mountain Dew.

Does it offend you if a immigrant who has no harm, cleans the McDonalds bathroom?

A little bit, because an american could be doing that job.