Make sure to specify who you're asking! (Chara or red.)

what

just to clarify, not a question
is chara alive and red's a ghost?

Originally red was a ghost. But the events of grouptale but pain has given them a physical form that they can turn on and off at will. Chara was like that from the start.

Red, can you still eat chocolate even though you're a ghost?
Chara, are you genocides?

Have you played any pvz game