From my POV Andrew is worse
Like, he might have a good side, but that doesn't change the fact that. he single handedly made Asriel, Giraffe, OsDe, and multiple other good users quit
I can't imagine that a single user left because of Jeffrey or Maze. Maybe someone left because of Danny, but definitely not as many people as because of Andrew.
Andrew also banned people for calling out pedophiles (Hannibal, Brattmann etc.), which doesn't make him much better as an actual pedo.