I prefer Tobey Maguire: I like his suit, I have the earliest memories of watching his movies, he's smug in the most comedic way possible, Spider-Man 2 gave us Pizza Time, he doesn't use web shooters, he is (canonically) the strongest of the three, and most importantly, between Maguire, Garfield and Holland, he is the ONLY Spider-Man who fought Venom in a live-action movie.