Here's a side-by-side

I think if u made the pose more like the old one it's be better

Come to think of it I may try drawing my new design in 2D

ok

I think the new one has a lot more detail and I like the shading to make it look a little bit 3-d

in my opinion
I like the old one

There's definitely some give and take. There's some things I like about the old one, and some things I like about the new one better.