I would take the stick

stick 100%

i dont care about rocks

Same here bro

They might be decent weapons tho

stick, kill the guy with the rock

Schtick

Same

Yes

Stick

Both
Stick for Melee
Rock for Range

Strock

Stick 100%

both

You can't. You can only pick one (unless you kill the offerer and steal both).

i stab him with the stick and grab the rock while hes stunned

yes

stick.

1. Take rock
2. Repeatedly smash the rock against the offerers head until he dies
3. Take the stick from him
4. You now have both 😄

You've now ruined the perfect rock

Stick