Chainsaw: Deadly AF but makes too much noise
Katana: Good if you know how to use it properly, requires alot of maintenence
Sledgehammer: Deadly in the hands of a true man, Really heavy to carry around
Broken bottle: You only use it a few times
Wooden stake: We're not hunting Vampires tho!
Box cutter: They're not even supposed to be lethal
Cutting board: Probably won't use it with a knife, not dense enough to kill
Any knife: Small, takes alot of stabs to kill.
Fireaxe: Deadly in the hands of a true Psychopath, A bit heavy, awkward to store, can cut wooden debris
Wooden Bat: Good but the metal bat would work better
Chopping Axe: Same as the fireaxe
Machete & Kukri: S H A R P, can cut debris
Kunais or Throwing stars: Quiet weapons, Ranged, won't kill instantly (Unless your a ninja)
Metal bat: Great sound, lighter than wooden bat, just as customizable as the wooden bat, an be concealed in a quivver
Frying Pan: Deadly in the hands of an angry Scott, Also makes great sound, concealable.
Hatchets: Throwable, can be dual weilded, can decapitate zombies, I can gather wood too.
Throwing hatchets: Hatchets, but throwings the best option
Compound bow: Various arrows, can use good ammo storage, can be stored in a bag
Survival Hatchet: Hatchet, but on steriods, great for scavenging recources, sure as hell it can kill
Nailgun: Can nail zombies to walls, good fortification tool, head shots are very lethal.
Crossbow: Low skill required to use, can modify like any normal firearm (Minus Suppressors), various bolts, iron sights, very accurate, compatable w/sling