I have a strong hunch this is why. Please read my comments.

are you sure about that

Not sure.

My icon is a dick

More like pigeon's face

If my previous comment made no sense it was because I thought your comment was on this imgflip.com/i/5u11rp

So yes, your icon is indeed rather phallic. 🤣

Is it possible to offer a higher detail custom icon to users who meet some kind of usage criteria? I understand there would be more work for imgflip mods as they would have to moderate icon submissions. Maybe after 100K points or maybe only for the top 250 list it wouldn't be too much work load. Please let me know your thoughts.

Yes! You’re right you can’t detail in the pfp. That’s the reason I became a brick wall: cuz I couldn’t make a goodlooking donut. A 12x12 grid should be nice

It is neat to see what people accomplish with as little as 5x5. Brick wall, reminds me of graphics tiles in old video games.

If you make the b*lls 2x2, then it may work.

I should have known that wasn't "a banana for scale"

I think you're 1 pixel away from a Nike Swoosh lawsuit.