Imgflip Logo Icon

Kropotkin is still better...

Kropotkin is still better... | ANARCHISTS; KROPOTKIN; MALATESTA | image tagged in memes,distracted boyfriend,anarchism,anarchist,communism,anarcho-communism | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
Distracted Boyfriend memeCaption this Meme
6 Comments
2 ups, 3y,
1 reply
A better writer, for sure. They all have their place, though.
1 up, 3y
You're right, you're right. Have you seen my stream btw?
imgflip.com/m/leftpolitics
[deleted]
0 ups, 3y,
1 reply
Distracted Boyfriend Meme | LYSANDER SPOONER ANARCHISTS MALTESTA
KROPOTKIN
AND ANY OTHER BIG GOVERNMENT IDIOT POSING AS AN ANARCHIST | image tagged in memes,distracted boyfriend | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
0 ups, 3y,
1 reply
Spooner was a socialist and member of the First International, but unfortunately was more individualist.

Just because communist is in the name does not make it supportive of big government, lmao.
[deleted]
0 ups, 3y,
1 reply
Is that what you tell yourself so you can sleep at night. I am not an anarchist but if I was I would mean it. There are a whole lot of Anarcho-Communists running around spouting Karl Marx these days. Which do those who are real anarchists, voluntaryists, etc are looking at them wondering if they realize what they are talking about.

Marx was a statist of the worst kind. His words inspired Lenin, Stalin, Hitler, Mussolini, Mao, Castro and many other totalitarian dictators. There is just no way to have a life without government and a life total government. They are polar opposites.

However, "Communism" is not a Marxist idea. And what Marx did with communism is not what communism meant. Communism is an idea where groups of people VOLUNTARILY live having all things in common. And if this wasn't the life you wanted you could leave.

Marx made it mandatory to have all things in common and there was no way out of his "commune".

Being an individualist is not "unfortunate". That is the natural state of those who are not malignant narcissists.
0 ups, 3y
Oh boy... lots wrong with what you said, so a bit to unpack here.

Lenin was absolutely inspired by Marx. Mussolini was while he was a syndicalist and a member of the Socialist Party of Italy, but would renounce class struggle in favor of class collaboration, which was an endorsement of corporatism, so he walked back on his prior socialist beliefs. Hitler on the other hand did not believe in Marxism at any point in his life. He had no converting to do. Leftists were resisting nationalism for the most part while he made it his identity. Even as Chancellor, he made it clear that "National Socialism" was not "Marxian socialism". For sure, it had everything to do with racial hierarchy, and nothing to do with worker-owned means of production.

Marx alone is not terrible, and should not be completely written off. Leninism is what introduced vanguardism, democratic centralism and resulted in totalitarianism. Marx has inspired generations of socialists and working class people. His critique of capitalism is one of the best, and many of his predictions were significant, many of the things he said were ahead of his time and there is much to learn from him. That said, there are things we shouldn't take from him. A "dictatorship of the proletariat" being the biggest one. Most anarchists are not Marxists, but many draw inspiration from Marx, and still insist on decentralization and oppose authoritarianism.

Alexander Berkman said anarcho-communism is truly voluntary communism. Even the anarchists in Spain amid the Civil War were careful to ensure collectivization was voluntary, and not repeat the same mistakes as Russia. All anarchist communists reject the idea that any laws or central authority would be necessary after the liberation from capitalism.

Individualism is unfortunate because their system still believes in markets and a strange concept of property. They also think violent revolution is just as bad as the abuses of the state (which is why individualists have never had any success). In reality, markets should be abandoned, money should be abandoned and no fictitious authority should govern whether someone eats, has shelter or has access to water or not. We operate best when we cooperate, and hold things in common.
Distracted Boyfriend memeCaption this Meme
Created with the Imgflip Meme Generator
IMAGE DESCRIPTION:
ANARCHISTS; KROPOTKIN; MALATESTA