Axol was my favorite SMG4 character

It should've been Melony. Axol didn't deserve to die.

Neither of them deserved death

Human Melony was the worst thing to ever happen to Axol's character imo. He got reduced to another simp, when we already have Bob, Fishy Boopkins, and Whimpu. Axol's character is what I'd describe as wasted potential.

So you're saying that Axol. The one that defeated Francis (AKA one of the worse SMG4 characters ever) and the one that comforted Meggy after Desti's death was a wasted pontential?

Bro, I literally ordered the plush toy, so of course I'm a fan
After Melony got turned into a human, yes. I'd argue that his potential wasn't being tapped into.
He could've benefitted from having an arc where he's the protagonist, and we see him grow as a character.
the Genesis Arc and Human Melony were disappointments for me as an Axol fan.

And that’s ok.