My ideas after these recent developments....

Uh sorry, tails...maybe

Crash and the imposter: friiiick no

or metal sonic
or silver
or knuckles
or eggman
or shadow

Ok, silver would be cool but shadow?

Hecc nah

Hecc yes!

No

but y

...its a sonic ripoff

how
and also, you don't want him in cause he's a ripoff?

It’s edglord sonic
And hey, we can get rid of daisy

I have 5 reasons why he should be in

1: he's iconic, it'll be really good for the franchise

2: He would be a great character in terms of rivalries

3: he could have a way better moveset

4: Ken is a ripoff Ryu, so is Ganondorf of Captain Falcon

5: Shadow is a spirit, he'd have good chances of being a fighter

Ok ok, makes sense but I personally don’t think he should be in...but

Shadow is an iconic villain, like Bowser! it's about time Sonic got a villain with him
also, It would be cool to have two villains in a row!

Nah, silver would be cooler

Silver is in the back of Green Hill Zone as well, he'd be unlikely

But he’d be better than shadow but hey..
I’ll ASSIST the idea

Who said assist trophies couldn't get in?

since assist trophies have never gotten in, there have been characters who were assist trophy one game then character the next (example: lil mac)

It’s a joke that shadow should stay as a trophy

I personally think that Assist trophies have as good a chance as anybody of getting in!

Your point?

See, Min Min was a spirit, She got in, Piranha Plant got in, He was a spirit!
Waluigi is the only exception to this!

spirits and assist trophies are two different things

Waluigi is the WOOOOOORRRST idea

Uhh, i think like 100% of people would disagree, Shadow is more iconic, and would kinda give Sonic a villan!

But hes just sonic but black, tails is more requested and hes on switch for sonic mania
(I’m pissed ray and mighty are DLC now)

(you could get the deluxe version, that's how I have them!)
Shadow isn't just black Sonic, he has Chaos Control and tails is in the background of green hill zone, he'd be highly unlikely to get in unlike Shadow

Shadow isn’t even that cool
Sorry fam

SHADOW SUCKS

Ok, Shadow is my favorite Sonic character, also, by insulting Shadow, that means you can't find a reason for him not to be in!

Haha...sorry but shadow just isn’t important all he does is get amnesia after a suicide mission

Shadow did do that, but he's a better candidate than Ralsei, who isn't as iconic if I didn't know who he was!

Ralsei doesn’t HAVE to be in but shadow? FOR SMASH..
Nice jokes

Ralsei? in smash?

Did. I. Say. I think ralsei will get in? No..it was a IDEA
Shadow is just the same loser

but what?

Hehe....well

you don't know why he shouldn't be in!

Not that

then what?

Heheh, i kinda want ralsei for smash

no, why would an oc get in?

It’s ralsei from deltarune

ok, why would Ralsei get in
(as a mii fighter maybe, idk about as an ACTUAL fighter)

Ok, here me out,
1. His game is on switch
2. He has abilities that make up an original moveset
3. Hes not hard to make, and he’s original unlike SOMEONE i know (shadow)
4. And yea a mii fighter would be fine but...i mean, it’s ralsei

look at mario's forward Ariel (i still cant spell)

The imposter is never gonna get in

he might

No...never...

maybe

No seriously

i am serious

No he will NEVER get in

why?

There just isnt much to go off of they’d be better as a assistant

but look at mario and luigi, most of they'er(i cant spell) move set is made up

It’s based on things they actually do to make a move set out of nothing...yea right

bRuH

maybe

No

why