Well, I'm born with a sinful nature in rebellion against God, therefore He created me as sinful. See the problem with that logic? God has declared His hate for sin, including homosexuality. The reason I am sinful and wretched is because the first Adam let sin into the world through his rebellion, which corrupted creation. That's why Jesus became a man and took on the rôle as the last Adam, to restore what the first Adam destroyed, and offers that restoration freely to those who put their trust in Him and His Word.
And, like I said, just because I'm tempted doesn't mean I'm powerless to resist.