I know Dumbledore ASKED Snape 2 ki|| him, but still...

He isn't forgiven

Its sad to see people forgive Snape. He doesn't deserve it!

Thank you someone agrees with me! My dad's argument is that Dumbledore was going to die anyways, but there could have been a miraculous cure! I think saying Snape's in the grey area is like saying Umbridge is the best thing that ever happened to Hogwarts. No. Just no.

Sure, perhaps Snape killed dumbldore on his orders, but Dumbledore did not ask him to ABUSE HARRY FOR ALL THE YEARS IN POTIONS! BLAMING YOUR ENEMYS SON IS HORRIBLE! Imagine if Snape didnt torment harry, perhaps a LOT of things would've gone different.

EXACTLY!!!! LILY PROBABLY MURDERED SNAPE AGAIN IN WIZARD HEAVEN (BECAUSE FOR SOME STRANGE REASON HE WOULD BE IN IT)

YAAASSSS!! And James wouldn't even try to stop her. He'd join in. So would Sirius. Oh man, Sirius would pummel him so many times. Cuz you can't die twice. Usually. Im sure Sirius had wanted to do it so many times after hearing what harry thought of Snape. BTW, if this comment doesn't make sense its cuz I have no idea what im typing. Its 1 am by me and at this point, my hands are usually doing their own thing.

It's 1 am here too. And Fred would probably also hurt him. And every student that died...

But would Dumbledore let them is the question...

Dumbledore technically can't stop them...

Even in death everyone would listen to him I feel

True, true... Except I'm pretty sure James didn't listen to him in real life

you're prob right. Tho Lily would, and James listens to lily...

THANK YOU SOMEONE AGREES

IM GLAD THAT JK ROWLING EXISTS CUZ WITHOUT HER, HARRY POTTER WOULDNT EXIST BUT WHY THE FUGGIN FUG DOES SHE KILL SO MANY GOOD CHARACTERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Better yet, why you gotta kill all the good characters, JK? Fred Weasley, Dobby, Hedwig, Severus Snape, Remus and Tonks, Alastor 'Mad-Eye' Moody, Sirius Black, Albus Dumbledore

I KNOW

dumbledore would have died any way even if snape didn't kill, due the ring

what is up with people dying because of a ring? first, LOTR, then HP

Ikr!

he was gonna die anyway, and it was all for saving harry....

true...