Shame on him lol
Sounds like you're reasonable about makeup, and I can certainly understand wanting some eyebrows. I have a unibrow like my dad lol. And as I get older it's getting the thick wirey hairs starting to grow just like his lol. Oh well.
I don't mind makeup as long as it's not plastered on. And a lot depends on the person. Some really do look better without it, and some I guess look ok with it. But no one looks good with a lot IMO. I just hate for women to feel like the makeup is what makes them attractive.