There is a much bigger difference between shotguns and AR's, but there are semi automatic shotguns as well. I have shotguns for bird hunting (dove & quail) and a shorter one for home defense. The shotgun makes a very distinct sound that everyone knows and could be heard when loading through our entire house. So if you load that weapon and then proceed through the house, no one in there right mind will remain in the house having heard that, which means if they are still there, they are there for bad intentions and should be shot. That is my perspective on home defense. In short, "the lock on the door you just kicked in, is there to protect you, not me".