Forgot that it doesn't show comments: So here is the evaluation:
The winner is Raydog.
Superdenny had a humor that appealed to me more than raydogs, but raydog lets his textcolor blend in artfully with the colors of the memes he used. Superdenny only uses colorless text which is something I rarely upvote. If I should point out a flaw with raydog it would be that most of his memes seems to be directly downloaded and stuffed out with a fitting text, but around 99% of topmemes are like that :D