Looks like Imgflip updated them. I've been here since 11/30/15.This is the first time I've seen it. How often do they do it?

Yeah, I noticed that too.

The last time I remember them changing it was about 9 months ago, when they took out Overly Attached Girlfriend, I Should Buy a Boat Cat, and (maybe) Scumbag Steve, and brought in Steve Harvey, Star Wars Yoda, and the Waiting Skeleton.

Here's a meme someone made about it:
imgflip.com/i/xp6lr

Oh, yeah... I wasn't NEAR as active back then, so it kind of escaped my notice, but now I DO remember OAG used to be a Popular Meme. I just assumed I remembered incorrectly (which has been known to happen) when it changed.

I wonder how they decide which gets categorized as Popular? The ones with the most memes made with them? But then, what if, say, OAG gets used in a lot of multi-template memes, they wouldn't boost her count any...

I'm obsessing over nothing again, aren't I? Stupid OCD...

I checked out that link... The comments were pretty fun. Many upvotes.