When I get into a one up situation, I look at it more for the fun aspect. This is the first place I've come across on the internet where people actually have fun doing it. I love it if I can't come up with a funny reply. It's the perfect applause for someone else. But you have to look at where I come from. I was a comic, and it's serious business. Once on stage, we'd often try to crack the other comics up while they would do the same to us. How did these adlib sessions work? Very well. The audience got a great show and we flexed our comedy muscles. But we never got vicious with each other. After a show, we'd stop off for a bite to eat and discuss the routines. I'd pull out my notebook and suggest this or that follow up line in their routine, or a different wording. I could always tell the comers from the guys that would be asking if you want fries with that from their reactions. The fry guys would look and say, "why would I say that" while the ones that moved up would come up with a way more natural to pull off the gag, or try it in their mouths to see how natural it "tasted" to them. The first writing I did for someone else was to have him flip the bird at the end of that bit. ET had just come out and, though I hadn't seen it, I realized he was doing a dead on impression. After the show, sitting at a diner, he said he didn't know how to close out the bit where ET saw his friends leave. He said he knew it had something to do with his fingers. I did his bit, but showed him watching the ship rise and had him flip the bird while saying "home". Doesn't read well, but in action, when he did it in the next show, it brought down the house.
I love it that there are people that I think are funnier than me so willing to share their humor, and they enjoy sharing mine. I hate it when a noob posts about how Raydog does so well with his " lame" memes. I look and see they've been here for a couple weeks, done four or five poor memes, no comments, and they can't figure out why they haven't got a million points. I can tell them, but they say that's too much work. When I started commenting on my original account, I couldn't get over how fast my points shot up. I did an afraid to ask Andy meme about it, and it went over like gangbusters because it was positive. I don't know how I got so many points. And at this point, I'm afraid to ask. I think you even commented. But I think I got more Comments because it wasn't a gripe but a good news meme about the site.