The fnaf thing isn't necessarily relevant when you take not of Pablo following the same point grinding streams and had the same point grinding methods as her and followed toady's other alts on their little trends
And as demonstrated by her Countryside alt, it's shown that it isn't difficult for her to try to impersonate another user, which i believe is somewhat connected to why Pablo acted like Mewo at certain times
My beliefs is that Toady was looking for ways to get Mewo in trouble, hence the pablo accusations drama
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand we should also take note that the one who admitted to being pablo was Whitney (Aka Anonymouse, aka Rosewater) who is suspiciously scarce on any sort of information on themself

There is a ton of evidence towards her being rosewater and pablo

She's really a disgusting person and we aren't letting a shell of human like her slide in our ranks
I don't see why it's so hard for people to understand that

There's a lot of holes to this statement, knowing her, the twitter guy could have been a lie to get herself out of trouble

So that checks out, Toady is rosewater and rosewater is pablo.