Imagination Spongebob

What this person is doing is in fact rejecting something on the grounds that it doesn't "sound right" to them, and fit their preconceived ideas. This is the opposite of true wisdom. You shouldn't be commending him for it.

"Just as, therefore, it would he the height of folly for a simple person to assert that what a philosopher proposes is false on the ground that he himself cannot understand it, so (and even more so) it is the acme of stupidity for a man to suspect as false what is divinely revealed through the ministry of the angels simply because it cannot be investigated by reason." - Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles (Book 1, Chapter 3, Section 4)

Bwahaha.

Put something into a context THEY don't like and suddenly they're quoting Long Dead Pedophiles at you.

"Judge not, lest ye be judged."