if you're looking for a way to stick with a religion that feels right - (ofc you know I'm an atheist so take this with a grain of salt) - might I recommend taking a step back from "typical" religions?
it seems reasonable to me that if there IS a god or higher power, it's nothing we'd know about or understand in the slightest. especially not formally in an "organized" religion. on top of this do you know how many of these there are? thousands. tens of thousands. maybe even hundreds of thousands. I don't see how you can just "pick" in your lifetime since you can't try every one.
so
my thought, is what if you "prayed" or "reached out" to something in a more ambiguous way? if there's a god, and it's comfortable with interacting with humanity at all, why not let it approach you? teach you more about it? after all, you can't be expected to believe a deity simply because you're told to, or taught. rather I hear it's supposed to be a personal thing. and what's more personal than discovering them yourself?