Okay I'll be logical, by fnaf's logic, Evan would win (as long as he has his flashlight) if he was skilled enough to know where nightmare fredbear is, but if not enough then nightmare fredbear would win, an by IRL logic, Evan would still win even if he doesn't close the doors, bcs the nightmares r just illusions traumatizing the kid they can't hurt him physical, but if the kid was a real crybaby, he would die from a heart attack and nightmare fredbear would win
(I don't even know if the crying child's real name is Evan 😭)