Gingerbread Man: pickles actually
Candystripe: she does really like candy canes, but it's really her mom's fettuccine alfredo that's her favorite
Awenasa: venison burgers - before she discovered them she just ate deer meat plain
Montie: PIZZA PIZZA PIZZA PIZZA PIZZA!!!!!!
Yansa: macaroni and cheese
Limitless Reaper: you'd think it'd be the flesh of a recently extinct species, but no, it's actually hot dogs