not a trampoline more like not that good

Trampline!!! Noooo! I'm Gonna Win is of course the best since it is a finished and tweaked Tally demo, Garden of Eden is rather good, Flamingo is an occasional bop, Old Bike is splendid, and.... everything else is.... questionable.
Sorry for taking so long to get your submission approved, I was on vacation. Bloody welcome to the Tally Hall stream!

im gonna win is a masterpiece, ghost & garden of eden are good songs but they remind me of a period of my life i would like to forget, & perfect is only good sometimes. i actually really don't like old bike, but it turns out a lot of people do. i also generally like music written by rob less whrn it comes to actual tally hall though, so it makes sense why i wouldn't like it that much¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

Can't believe I forgot Perfect! I love Perfect! A few of Rob's songs for TH are good, it sucks he kinda dominated in G&E when songs with all three's vocals are always a win. Anything from MMMM that Rob sang [Greener, Be Born, Just Apathy, Haiku] are *really* good in my opinion, very pleasing, immature love songs. But G&E? Ehhh... G&E in general has a very strict sound in comparison to MMMM, but I'm not nearly the first person to notice this. Never Meant to know is ok, but boring. You & Me is like a less angsty Greener. Who You Are is like Be Born but not as,,, unique. Out In The Twilight would have been so much better with Zub's voice honestly. Also Time Machine's demo was SO FUSSING GOOD but the actual performance of it for HPTII is NOT it, I have mixed feelings about the altered vocal effect. Rob's style is definitely more mainstream, which is why he is arguably the most popular of the quintet in the eyes of non-halligans.

im really not a huge fan of be born/haiku/you & me to be honest. greener & just apathy are really good in my opinion. never meant to know is really calming & i really like it. i love who you are but also i love fantasy things & good & evil so i guess that would make sense. out in the twilight would definitely be better with zubin's vocals. i also love all of miracle musical but i think excluding the mind electric, the studio versions are better than the demos. but also i absolutely love light & night, i'm the most mad that didn't release on any of the studio albums. i honestly think joe has the best writing style & vocals in my personal opinion, but i can see why people like rob, it really just isn't my favourite (there are still some bangers though)

Joe is definitely what makes Tally Hall what it is. I love Joe Hawley so so much [I'm his #6 listener on Spotistats!]. I think Haiku is totally hidden in the sand; it's so fussing underrated. Be Born is a hit or miss with most fans, it grew on me. Never Meant to Know is in fact very calming, I never said I dislike it [I love all Tally Hall-adjacent songs] though I wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it. Andrew's complex, washing keyboard line in NMTK is very impressive. Who You Are is a very good song. Since you mentioned fantasy things, I LOVE Sacred Beast, it has to be one of my favorites, it is possibly one of the most CHAWESOME songs on G&E. The Trap is also really great, it became one of my favorites once I listened to the demo. I also wish Fate of the Stars were preformed as Mind Control in the studio recording, the pace was more engaging to me, but altering it to be slower works as a good closing song of the album. I think Zubin should have had more songs in general, maybe the third album will feature him on a lot more. His voice has really developed as heard in Rotary Park and White Ball. I think Light & Night should be released as an official song on Spotify because the Magician's Elephant recording of it is the pretrack for the recent repress. Oh also it has its own single along with Turn The Lights Off??? Mucka Blucka and Dream are both bonus tracks and are on Spotify, why not Light & Night? Justice for Light & Night! Joe definitely has the best vocals and I'm so thankful he pursued music more intensely than the other members did since the hiatus. Joe has written the most beautiful songs and, as I said, is what makes Tally Hall what it is.