WAIT A FLIPPING MINUTE
Right before Belos (possesing Hunter) was going to kill Flapjack (by sucking his soul or something like that) he said, and I quote, "Goodbye Evelyn."; Is Evelyn actually Flapjack, so after Caleb's death, she could still be by him, even though it's not him? (Through the clones of Caleb, aka the Grimwalkers)