Just gonna post the oldest meme on imgflip here

1a is older

How

You don’t have clear proof
Both are posted 12 years ago

Did you check the time the 3rd reply was made

It was made 3 months ago, so at that time it said that imgflip.com/i/9 was made 11 years ago

Seriously
Do you even have proofs other than comments

I could try and use the Wayback machine

1a is not archived

But is the fact the number is lower not proof?

?