Both sides are guilty of "nut picking"; where you find the worst example of someone who holds a belief and make them the representative of all people who hold this belief.
Some good recent examples are:
You think that there might be cures to covid other than vaccines, so you must agree with the people who think drinking pee is a cure for covid, and
You belive in non traditional sexual norms, so you must agree with the people who believe that pedophilia is natural and good.