So the plot doesn't make sense. That's not an objective point, that's subjective based on your perception of it. What about the plot doesn't make sense to you?
I said I had a long list of arguments. Counter-arguments are arguments.
My claim is that critics of the sequels can't logically find anything wrong with the trilogy without stepping on other media in the Star Wars Universe. In order to show-case my arguments, you need to make points for me to address as I see nothing horrifically wrong with the sequel that would warrant the collective hate by this division of the Star Wars "Fans." Which, segues into my next point...
You called me a "prequel fanboi." You misunderstand. I am a Star Wars Fan. In the truest sense of the term. Fan, being derived from fanatic. In this, you could call me a true Star Wars Fan.
Fan.
A fan, aficionado, or supporter is someone who has an intense, occasionally overwhelming liking and enthusiasm for a sporting club, person, group of persons, or trend. Fans constitute a fanbase or fandom. They often show their enthusiasm by starting a club, blogging, or promoting the object of their interest.